Uniting Ideas Essays

FOR A UNITED NI IN A BETTER UK

Submit an essay

To submit an essay as part of our Uniting Ideas series please contact hello@niin.uk

Defining Unionism in a Changing Britain

Why Unionism is Losing

James Alexander Smith provides an urgent diagnosis of a movement he believes is currently “losing”. He argues that traditional Unionism is built upon three historic pillars that are now crumbling: a shared ethnocultural identity, a robust institutional framework (such as the Monarchy and the NHS), and a security guarantee against nationalist dominance. Smith posits that as Great Britain undergoes rapid secularisation and demographic change, the “Britain” that Ulster Unionists once pledged loyalty to is essentially vanishing, leaving the movement adrift and reactive.

The essay proposes a radical shift in strategy: Unionism as a Cultural Ark. Instead of merely following the political trends of the mainland, Smith argues that Northern Ireland should become the primary custodian of traditional British values, history, and Protestant identity. By moving away from “navel-gazing” election cycles and towards long-term cultural reproduction (investing in the arts, legal defence bodies, and international lobbying) Smith suggests Unionists can transform their community from a defensive voting bloc into an indispensable, culturally rooted asset that makes the maintenance of the Union the “path of least resistance” for any future government.

Click here to read this essay

The Character of the Union

Unity and Diversity

Professor Arthur Aughey provides a rebuttal to the popular narrative that the United Kingdom’s dissolution is a historical inevitability. Rather than viewing Brexit or COVID-19 as the final “catastrophes” leading to an “end time”, Aughey reframes the UK as a dynamic “multinational state” (a hybrid entity that successfully bridges the gap between unity and diversity). He argues that the Union survives not through rigid central control, but through a flexible constitutional arrangement that allows local patriotisms to flourish within a wider framework of collective solidarity.

The essay introduces the compelling concept of “elective affinity”, suggesting that the Union is a conscious, ongoing choice made by its component nations to share risks and pool resources. Aughey contrasts the “soaring dove” idealism of independence movements with the practical, “instrumental” benefits of British citizenship, such as shared welfare and economic security. By moving the conversation from abstract “national values” to the tangible realities of law, history, and mutual support, Aughey offers a masterclass in understanding the “hidden wiring” that keeps the UK together in an era of deep political uncertainty.

Click here to read this essay